Radical Honesty – How to Transform Your Life by Telling the Truth
Brad Blanton
PP.55-58
Manipulating and strategizing and having secret plans and conspiracies is one way to operate in the world to create the appearance of a successful life. But the appearance of a successful life is to a successful life as the menu is to a meal. The
appearance of success is a performance in which you are cut off from contact with the audience except through your role.
A successful life, in contrast, is one in which you can share with others openly, as your life happens, without all that rehearsal. The contrast is between performance and sharing. The alternative to telling the simple truth about your feelings and thoughts, as they occur, is a kind of pathetic bragging one is left with in later life even if one has made money – the usual measure of success – but remained an isolated manipulator.
Manipulation
never works to get the result desired, but it always seems like it’s just about to work. When you get what you said you wanted by manipulation, it is never enough. When you tell the truth and get what you want, getting what you want is like gravy – it feels like you are getting more than you ever hoped for, rather than just oaky but not quite good enough.
We all get to make this choice between manipulation and communication over and over again in life. John Stevens, a Gestalt educator, wrote beautifully in his book,
Awareness, about the dilemma of trying to win love through manipulation as opposed to communicating.
A great deal has been written about trust and love, and that if you can build a strong trusting, loving relationship, then people can be honest with each other. I believe this idea is exactly backwards. It is very nice if I feel trusting and loving toward someone, but if I don’t feel this way, what can I do about it? Trust and love are my
feeling responses toward another person, and these responses cannot be manufactured. Either I feel love or I don’t. All the emphasis on trust and love results in many people
pretending to feel trust and love "because it is healthy, and will bring about closeness, honesty, etc." – adding a new area of phoniness and dishonesty in their behavior.
Honest, however, is a
behavior and
is something I can choose or not choose. I cannot decide to love or trust, but I can decide to be personally honest or not. And when I choose to be really honest and say what I experience and what I feel, I am showing that I can be trusted.
This is the
only kind of behavior that can bring about a response of trust. Trust is my response to a person that I know I can believe. Even if I dislike a person, I can trust him if he is honest with me, and I can respect his willingness to be himself honestly.
Likewise, honesty does not always bring a response of love, but it is absolutely essential to it. When I am honestly myself, and you respond warmly and with caring, then love exists. If I calculate and put on a phony behavior in order to please you, you may love my
behavior, but you cannot love
me, because I have hidden my real existence behind this artificial behavior. Even when you love in response to my phony behavior, I cannot really receive your love. It is poisoned by my knowledge that the love is for the image I have created, not for me. I also have to be continually on guard to be sure that I maintain my image so that your love does not disappear. Since I have shut myself off from your love in this way, I will feel more lonely and unloved, and try even more desperately to manipulate myself and you in order to get this love.
In contrast, when I am honestly myself and you respond to be as I am in that moment, I can receive this fully and know the satisfaction of being really related with you. This honest relating is not always joyful or pleasant – it is sometimes sad, sometimes angry, etc. – but it is always
solid and
real and
vitally alive.